Changes in the Comments – Editing and Sharing the Love

Pin It

One of the coolest things about blogging is the interaction that occurs when people comment. It’s not unusual here to have a better discussion in the comments than the original post provides.

I truly appreciate those readers that take the time and effort to comment. Well, I truly appreciate every reader, even those that never comment (and like everywhere out there, most readers never comment).

I’ve just added a few features here on Phoenix Real Estate Guy that provides a little incentive and reward for those that comment, and I’ve tried to make it a little easier for commenters by adding comment editing.

DoFollow

I suspect most people are not aware that links in blog comments are initially set up as “nofollow” links. This means the search engines basically ignore the links. I’ve been a “Do Follow” adopter from the beginning of the ‘do follow movement’. Comment links here ARE followed by Google and other search engines. For more info, Dave Smith has a great article on Do Follow.

CommentLuv

I’ve just installed the CommentLuv plugin. This will automatically search for a feed from your blog (assuming you put your blog into the “Website” field in the comment form) and put a link to your last post at the bottom of your comment. In theory, this may entice readers of this blog to check out your latest comment — which helps your traffic, and that link is also followed, which gives you a little more link love. There’s an example in the image at the bottom of this post. Note: It will take a few seconds for the system to “find” your last post, please be patient! And if your RSS feed isn’t auto-detectable, it won’t find it at all.

KeywordLuv

I’ve also just installed KeywordLuv. While the “Luv” suffix is getting annoying, this is a pretty nifty plugin. It’s common to see commenter names like “Timbuktu Real Estate” or “Hotshot Lawyer”, particularly in DoFollow blogs. This is because people know that adding key words to links containing their URL, they get “extra credit” from search engines. With KeywordLuv, you can leave Your name AND keywords, and the system will create the link with your key words.

All you have to do is enter ‘Your Name@Your keywords’ in the comment form name field.

Like this:

Keywordluv example

That will display as in the example below.

With this, we can all get your name — helps with the whole “community building thing” and you get your keywords.

Reply – Quote other comments

As you can see in the example below, there are now links in the comments that will enable you to reply to a specific comment and quote a comment. I haven’t played with this feature yet, but it’s a part of what appears to be a very cool plugin, WP Comment Remix. UPDATE: This one is acting a bit wonky, so I’m going to turn off the reply/quote function.

Most Active Commentators

Somewhere along the way, I lost the Top Commentators out of the side bar. It’s back, currently residing in the bottom of the first side bar. This is a list of the most active commentators (by number of comments). The count resets each month to zero. If you want a picture / logo to show up there, go to Gravatar.com (this will also add a pic/logo in the comments area). This list is part of the Comment Remix plugin linked above.

Comment Editing

I am a lousy typist. I can type fairly fast, but I have to look at the keys and I make mistakes. I’ve left countless typos scattered across the Internet. In the vast majority of blogs, once you type a comment and click “submit”, your comment is committed and there is nothing you can do to correct silly typos.

That’s no longer an issue on Phoenix Real Estate Guy! You will now have up to 15 minutes after you submit a comment to edit it (or your name, email or URL). 15 minutes seems long enough to me, but if someone thinks they’ll need more time, just… well, leave a comment!

This feature was implemented with Ajax Edit Comments 2.0.

Just for Grins

A few days ago, I added a “Widget Test Area” at the bottom of the far right column. Things may appear here only fleetingly, or they may earn a permanent spot somewhere. Who knows. If you ever see something there and you want more info on it, just ask!

Here’s an example of all these things in action. As always, I reserve the right to change anything or everything! I’d love to hear your thoughts and opinions on these changes!

Comment and keyword luv

Like, Tweet, share...

Pin It

 

Other things you can do...

Search for Homes
Email Updates
RSS

About the Author
Jay Thompson

I'm a real estate broker in Phoenix, Arizona and the publisher of the Phoenix Real Estate Guy blog. I tend to drive too fast and scream at the University of Texas and Denver Broncos football teams. My two kids are smarter than most adults I know and my wife is simply amazing.

The Phoenix Real Estate Guy runs on AgentPress

AgentPress is a specialized WordPress theme for real estate agents and brokers, powered by the industry standard Genesis Framework. With AgentPress on your team, you're empowered to get the most out of WordPress for online marketing.

Genesis provides the secure and search-engine-optimized foundation that powers any successful website. And AgentPress provides the specific listing and lead-generation functionality real estate pros need to succeed.

Find out more about AgentPress here.

Comments

We always appreciate your comments! Phoenix Real Estate Guy uses two commenting systems, Facebook and LiveFyre. LiveFyre is the most robust system (and easy to use!). It allows you to login with Twitter, Facebook, Google+ LinkedIn, OpenId, LiveFyre and as a "Guest". I recommend getting a LiveFyre account, it has some great features (just click the LiveFyre button when you write your comment).

 

BLOG COMMENT POLICY: We respectfully ask that you use your real name (first name only is fine) and not use keywords (Why no keywords?). The only real "comment rules" are be civil -- no personal attacks -- and no advertising. (See the full comment policy here). Opinion and debate are welcome, but attack the idea, not the person.

 

LiveFyre Comments

Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest

you are generous. The whole attitude around here is amazing! It's like you trust people or something. liberar samsung

They're afraid of having a spate of a few hundred of those 3-worded comments like "good post" or "keep up the good work" kinda thing. maxidus

I am an avid promotor of the Dofollow Movement! We shall conquer. To me, nofollow is opression, trying to silence people from leaving what THEY consider spam. What they think is spam and what I consider spam may be two entirely different things. If you don’t like my comment, thinking its spam, then scroll past it! Is that so hard?

My recent post What Women Want in Bed

Congratulations on making the site a Dofollow with excellent comment plugin, the CommentLuv! I really luv it.
.-= Xandra Hasegawa´s last blog ..How to Screw Up Your Relationship with a Japanese Woman =-.

Some people are afraid that there will be more comment spams after putting up "you comment I follow" or "comment/keyword-luv". They're afraid of having a spate of a few hundred of those 3-worded comments like "good post" or "keep up the good work" kinda thing. What i find on my personal blog, really is that i indeed have a little more of such comments, but it really encouraged more quality comments to emerge. It's a little pain for a huge gain -- to be able to know what our readers think and feel about what we write. Most readers do not leave comments, and if we want to encourage readers who are also webmasters to leave comments, this may be the best thing we can do.

Some people are afraid that there will be more comment spams after putting up "you comment I follow" or "comment/keyword-luv". They're afraid of having a spate of a few hundred of those 3-worded comments like "good post" or "keep up the good work" kinda thing. What i find on my personal blog, really is that i indeed have a little more of such comments, but it really encouraged more quality comments to emerge. It's a little pain for a huge gain -- to be able to know what our readers think and feel about what we write. Most readers do not leave comments, and if we want to encourage readers who are also webmasters to leave comments, this may be the best thing we can do.

Hmmm... judging by Steve's reply/quote in his comment, that one needs a little work. I'm going to turn that off until I have some time to work on it.

Keyword Luv is an amazing tool.. I love the concept. I ll definitely implement it on my blog asap. Thanks for sharing.

Well, i think you guys said it all... This plugin is one of the coolest around :) Its great but i think a minimum of control is needed to prevent spammers getting in. Thanks for sharing.

Keyword Luv is a great alternative to comment luv for people who do not have a blog on their site! If you do have a blog on your site, both work great together!

nofollow has been developed by yahoo, google and MSN. other day i have noticed MSN message board still use dofollow and most of them flooded by vigra site owners :p

Do follow is a great way to bring people to your blog and contribute opinions and ideas as well as receive some benefit from the effort. thanks!

Thanks to the 'doFollow' movement and to you of course :) - Mike

**Mike´s last blog post..Science and it’s quirks</abbr></abbr>

Bloggers who use KeywordLuv and CommentLuv attract more traffic and also reward their visitors. It seems to be a win-win situation and everybody is happy. But, someone need to create a plug-in that will effectively keep those pesky spammers away!

**Hanna´s last blog post..Watch Live Academy Awards — the Oscars</abbr></abbr>

This article is fantastic - a great way to show repsect to your readers and to encourage a bit of debate…sometimes people need a bit of a push/incentive to do so! I’m sure you’ll have seen traffic increase significantly though as a result, at least I hope so!

Hi,

The page rank formula still plays a role. I love the keywordluv plugin. For a blogger, link building through do-follow commenting is one of the necessary evils.

Thanks.

I'm not a very good typist myself. It's good that you'd still be able to edit your comments even after you've posted it. At least you'll have time to review it. Keyword luv is a very good technology to improve the traffic of your site.

Keyword luv is great for people who cannot use comment luv because the site they are trying to promote doesn't have a blog. Thanks for the share!

**George´s last blog post..Digital Imaging Review: Kodak Dental 9000 3D System</abbr></abbr>

Jay,

Since my SEO guy got me started, the one place I know I can go FIRST and improve my coming day is RIGHT HERE. Always thoughtful, always on point, always pushing the envelope. Have fun in DC baby! Please tell everyone I said "GO PENS! SEE YA NEXT YEAR CAPS"

Navy Chief, Navy Pride

**Joe´s last blog post..April Showers, May Flowers?</abbr></abbr>

That is exactly what Keyword Luv and Comment Luv are intended to do - get blogger's audience involved and participating. We love them.

**Hanna´s last blog post..Privacy Policy</abbr></abbr>

These plugins definitely get more readers and commentators involved. They also build relationships within the blogger community, too. But, I hope it's not just about improving your rankings with backlinks: we all have a stake in furthering meaningful discourse in the blogsphere with strong grammar, proper punctuation and compelling content. As Thomas Paine once wrote, "What we obtain too cheap, we esteem too lightly."

HI, i've been trying this technique with keyword love and have to admit, this is damn good ! Excellent post. Thanks for sharing the luv. All the best. Jeff

Keyword Luv is a great alternative to comment luv for people whose sites don't have a feed.

I’m thinking about adding CommentLuv to my site but have heard it can be a strain on your database. KeywordLuv seems to be a “lighter” application so I may try that one first.

I love the keywordluv plugin. For bloggers, link building through do-follow commenting is one of the necessary evils. It's hard work but at the end it pays as it brings additional traffic to the site.

Jay,

I am impressed that a real estate guy is so internet savy! Comments, Twitter, Thesis powerful theme, and who knows what else!

In these tough real estate times an agent has to find the "edge".

Keep up the good work!

Bob

**Bob´s last blog post..10 Easy Steps To Save Money On your Energy Bill</abbr></abbr>

the keyword luv plugin has worked wonders for me to increase traffic to my sites and links. and I'm a personal fan of do follow, too...I believe in providing a regulated environment upon which users can share ideas and process them while putting together a comment.

I think keyword luv is a great idea, it can sure and hell give you a whole lot more traffic to your blog that can turn into click for your adsense ads. Can't beat that right!

Thank you really. This is the information that I've been looking for.

These are great plugins, thanks for sharing the info. I'm definitely going to install them on my blog once I get it up and running. It really helps to get people commenting on your posts and adds to the popularity of your site.

I think this plug in is great! While I'm sure it can be annoying with some posting just spam comments, it does intice your readers to leave more comments. It's a win win situation for both sides. The commenter gets a little link love and the blog owner gets a more active blog.

i like these plug-ins and I actually use it to one of my blogs except the dofollow one. I can't still figure out how to do it yet and aside from that I have some reservations about it and I am not sure what will be the side effect of dofollow on my site's presence online.

I just started using the feature so I cannot comment on how well it works, but I like the idea. I do wonder if it will hurt your SERPs at all with a lot of outgoing links.

I think you'll find that using the comment Luv plugin will greatly increase the comments that you get to your site, if you can whittle out the blatantly spammy ones that offer no value however, you are left with some pretty decent feedback. I've used it on one of my blogs to great effect.

**Pierre´s last blog post..You either love it or you hate it</abbr></abbr>

Nice Review.i interested with this article and useful information.

**gorge´s last blog post..Lilly Donates $1 Million To Help Veterans Of Iraq, Afghanistan</abbr></abbr>

I'm currently on blogger, but the more I read about these 'luv' plugins the bigger the argument gets to switch to wordpress. Not ready to make the plunge yet, but it appears the day is coming.

**JCL´s last blog post..Smartkey Locks, Excellent For Landlords Who Want To Quit Calling The Locksmith</abbr></abbr>

Taking part in the dofollow revolution is really commendable. For me it allows me to take part in conversations and also feel that I'm not just twitterring away my time cause I'm getting a little SEO boost by commenting. It makes it worthwhile to join in on the conversation. So good.

I've never seen the twitter ID field though. Where'd you get that?

Phil

I never realized that there is a proper commenting procedure that allows linking benefits. I just heard that putting merely you name and main website produces little results. Thanks to keyword luv - such a great plug in.

**Ernesto´s last blog post..Solar Lighting - Illumination and other Important Benefits You can Enjoy</abbr></abbr>

hey, what a good idea. I can see it seems to be working well, Judging by the number of comments you have here. Well done!

I think that those of you that use the keyword luv plugin should commended for your desire to offer a place for relevant comments to be posted while at the same time getting great content posted to your blog. If more bloggers would realize the potential power of such an application, many more bloggers would welcome commenting that would allow the participant to make an on topic post that would in turn increase the publishers content and at the same time allowing the commentor to receive a link back to their own blog with an anchor.

**shawn´s last blog post..Clean Red Widgets On The Attack</abbr></abbr>

@Alex - thanks for the feedback on your experiences with the Keyword Luv plug-in I will be incorporating it shortly.

@Jay - I thought you might find it interesting that the comment luv plug-in also picks up posts made in vBulletin forums. So, maybe it works for anything that has a RSS feed set up.

I installed the Keyword Luv plug-in on our real estate blog in San Diego and it really has been interesting to see and track some of the comments. I think that you have to be careful with spam but you also get a lot more participation in your blog and it gets other people involved who might not have participated in the past. I think the plug-in has been a big success.

**Alex´s last blog post..Como duele.</abbr></abbr>

Plugins like these are really a great way to get people to read your blog posts. This works best if you wish to market your ideas to a wide audience. For Phoenix real estate, I'm not sure that the benefits outweight the negatives.

This really does seem like a nifty little plugin, it will definitely encourage more comments on your blog and hence more traffic.

thanks.

These are all great plugins and the help the community if you ask me. The key is you will need to do more moderation because you will get more spammers. But if you can get a few new readers then all the better!

Jay - I'm still new to blogging and I've learned much of what I know from following your blog. These new tools take your site to an even higher level. Well done!

*Tina Fountains last blog post..Living in Cobb County 2008 Fact Book</abbr>

Jay,

I think that these are some Great new tools, and I am looking forward to trying to use them within my blog.

Edge - thanks for providing that link! Even if that test says it's OK, there can still be reasons CommentLuv can't find someone's last post. Apparently it only tries for about 3 seconds and if it can't find it, it bails out (makes sense, otherwise it could hang forever). Several connections and things have to be done in that three seconds. If any one thing fails, then no last post will be displayed

It's also imperative of course to understand that the URL must be typed correctly and it will only pick up blog posts, not static web pages.

Linsey (and others) - the little corner flip thingy is a little painful to install. There is a plugin that I never got to work. So I configured the javascript files it contains myself (they are pretty well documented), created the "look here" image and the image that shows when the corner is flipped, and uploaded the images and javascript files to the blogs server. I had to doink around with where the script file are saved, and where in the blog theme header to put the calls to the javascript. The plugin/files are here.

Ned - the math anti-spam is a plugin. It is here.

I think what you are doing here with comments is a great idea. More blogs should incorporate these plugins and techniques. Not only does this help commenters in SEO but it helps the blog owner in social proof and credibility.

*Blossoms last blog post..Aurora, Colorado</abbr>

Facebook Comments

 

The ARMLS logo indicates a property listed by a real estate brokerage other than Thompson's Realty.
All information should be verified by the recipient and none is guaranteed as accurate by ARMLS.

Copyright 2012 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

Data last updated 2/9/12 8:33 AM PST.

This IDX solution is (c) Diverse Solutions 2012.