FHA Buyers: Phoenix housing market 2nd class citizens

.

Call me an infrequent flyer.

Last week, I stood in the long line at the Phoenix Sky Harbor security checkpoint like a lamb being led to slaughter. The short line, the one that guys in fancy suits get to use, was strictly forbidden because I didn’t know the secret handshake. I also lacked preferred silver diamond elite status.

I boarded the plane with the Zone 5’ers and passed by the first class passengers as they sipped their free booze and closed multi-million dollar deals on their smartphones. Worse, these stuffy elitists refused to make eye contact with me as I made my way to coach, where I would go to suffer with the rest of the commoners for the next three hours.

(Make sure you follow Marty on Twitter here)

Then it dawned on me as I took my middle seat in aisle 27. I’m a 2nd class citizen of the air travel world.

In case you haven’t heard the news, the greater-Phoenix area is a seller’s market again. Inventory levels are down and prices are up. Cash buyers accounted for 40% of all sales in March. And this new phenomenon has turned FHA loan approved buyers into the 2nd class citizens of the housing market.

Why?

For starters, FHA loan approved buyers have very little, if any, cash to put down on their home purchase. In rapidly appreciating markets like Phoenix it’s difficult for appraisers to keep up with values. If you’re a home seller or fix and flipper like me and are under contract with an FHA buyer what happens if your house doesn’t appraise for the offer price? You either lower it to match the appraised value or put the house back on the market. Neither option is very attractive.

If you’re a home seller and are under contract with an FHA buyer and the house does appraise you’re still not out of the woods. The FHA requires a second appraisal, usually ordered about 5-7 days prior to closing. The FHA honors the lower of the two.

Then there’s the inspection. The FHA has a laundry list of stuff that must be done in order for them to approve a buyer’s loan. Last year, I flipped a house to an FHA approved buyer that didn’t ask for any repairs. After the home inspection was complete the FHA came back and required I fix a bunch of stuff – to the tune of $1,500. Even worse, they had to send the inspector back at my expense to verify the items had been corrected, which pushed out the closing one week.

This is why many FHA borrowers are getting squeezed out of the market. They are the last people a home seller wants to deal with. Sellers here know that over asking price offers likely won’t appraise. The only way to get a deal done is to find a cash buyer, or a conventional buyer with enough cash to cover the difference if the appraisal comes back low.

So if you’re an FHA approved buyer what do you do?

I recommend you put more money down. That lets the seller know you can at least make up some of the difference if the appraisal doesn’t match the offer price. If you don’t have any money to put down then save some and buy later. Homeownership is not a life or death proposition.

The alternative is you get treated like a 2nd class citizen. But take it from me; it’s not that bad. Just be prepared to wait in a long line before finally getting to your seat.

You should follow Thompsons Realty @ThompsonsRealty

Photo Credit

Comments

comments

Like, Tweet, share...

.

 

Other things you can do...

Search for Homes
Email Updates
RSS

About the Author
Marty Boardman

Marty Boardman is the owner and Chief Financial Officer for Rising Sun Capital Group, LLC, a real estate investment firm in Gilbert, Arizona. His company flips 30-40 homes a year. Marty is also a Realtor for Thompson’s Realty. He writes about his investments and the greater-Phoenix housing market at http://flippingphoenixhouses.com. Marty is an accredited instructor for the Arizona Department of Real Estate and teaches a 3-hour agency law class called “Attracting Investor Clients”.

The Phoenix Real Estate Guy runs on AgentPress

AgentPress is a specialized WordPress theme for real estate agents and brokers, powered by the industry standard Genesis Framework. With AgentPress on your team, you're empowered to get the most out of WordPress for online marketing.

Genesis provides the secure and search-engine-optimized foundation that powers any successful website. And AgentPress provides the specific listing and lead-generation functionality real estate pros need to succeed.

Find out more about AgentPress here.

Comments

We always appreciate your comments! Phoenix Real Estate Guy uses two commenting systems, Facebook and LiveFyre. LiveFyre is the most robust system (and easy to use!). It allows you to login with Twitter, Facebook, Google+ LinkedIn, OpenId, LiveFyre and as a "Guest". I recommend getting a LiveFyre account, it has some great features (just click the LiveFyre button when you write your comment).

 

BLOG COMMENT POLICY: We respectfully ask that you use your real name (first name only is fine) and not use keywords (Why no keywords?). The only real "comment rules" are be civil -- no personal attacks -- and no advertising. (See the full comment policy here). Opinion and debate are welcome, but attack the idea, not the person.

 

LiveFyre Comments

Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Sports Preview 13 pts

The information you have on this blog is so good that I wouldn’t mind paying to be able to access it.  Great resource, anyway. Shouldn’t be complaining. Thanks.

lawyer 55 pts

I Agree with Texas payday loans

Realhomesestate 5 pts

What i read here is something to be put in mind about FHA. I've been informed as well.

Great post, I don't have a background about FHA but I learn from your post since I am in a real estate agency too but in France <a href="http://prorassur.fr/">Agence immobilière vichy</a>

People in first class didn't look at you so you label yourself as a second class citizen?  Weird.  I don't make a point to look at people walking through the isles either, regardless of my seat location.  I'd say your comment indicates more a lack of self worth rather than an indication of what others think of you.

RJeffery 5 pts

Thank you for the great post Marty.  I really enjoyed the read.

Great article Marty... 

I wish I could say I have never seen a more ignorant nor arrogant comment. I imagine you lack education or colorful life experience in the world of most people who are buying homes unfortunately from you. I for sure would never be one of them.Not only do I have 75% of the cash to put down on a home in the price range i am looking for. I'm not even looking for an FHA loan. However, do to granite slapping on inferior designed kitchens and clean paint job, which I am most competent of choosing my on preference in color and enjoy the quality of my technique, I won't pay more than recent comps square footage, neighborhood and natural price progression that the economy warrant.  To do so reflects lack of understanding in what it does to the community, economy and on the lesser end puts unwarranted dollars in the greedy pockets of people like you. I find too many buyers and sellers lack the will not the intelligence to do the research in determining what the "market price" refers to. It is important for our environment to be healthy and have real value to understand more than shallow opinions.

That's was really interesting experience and the post as well. The topic about FHA is really great. Thanks

champagne 5 pts

It is really nice to read you !

 

Good job !

Ajnara Ambrosia Noida 5 pts

Marty, great post! FHA does not require a second appraisal on flips unless your showing 50% or greater profit. Thanks for this post.

Gulshan Ikebana 5 pts

Its really nice to read it.Thanks for this post.

jglynn 7 pts

Some people use FHA financing strategically - maybe they have a larger down payment, but wish to retain capital for improvements or other purposes. FHA underwriting is more liberal than other programs in many situations. Common concerns raised about FHA-based offers include the notion that a buyer using FHA signifies weakness, or (something else we frequently hear) a higher risk of delays. Both of these are misconceptions that should be investigated further before making any assumption. 

Marty, great post! FHA does not require a second appraisal on flips unless your showing 50% or greater profit. Your buyer's lender may have an overlay that requires it but if you're making more than 50% consider that a small price to pay.

When you're flipping homes, it's likely you are your best comp. It's a model match, within a quarter of a mile and less than 90 days ago. So justifying the higher sales price puts the burden on you.

 

We're seeing the same thing her in Bend.  FHA buyers have a slim chance in mulitiple offer situations.  Sellers don't want to take on FHA loans, because they know that there are too many things that can go wrong.  That being said, I have closed several transactions with FHA loans this year. I was talking with a mortgage broker the other day about this.  He said that with FHA premiums at an all time high, if the buyer can afford another 1.5% (5% total) down payment, they would be better off going conventional.  The problem is that many FHA buyers don't have good enough credit to go conventional. 

Well said, Marty! I've heard estimates that we're going to be suffering with low inventory through the summer. Which means is going to a long, hot few months for many buyers.

Facebook Comments

Comments

comments

 

More in Phoenix Real Estate (41 of 282 articles)