Sarasota Association of Realtors Railroads One of their Own

by Jay Thompson on October 25, 2008 · 48 comments
Written by: Jay Thompson

in Blogging / Social Networking

Sarasota Association of Realtors Railroads One of their OwnThe Sarasota Association of Realtors (SAR) has been all over the real estate blogs of late. There are many posts out there detailing the story with the seminal post being Sarasota Association of Realtors Domain Theft by Morgan Carey of Real Estate Webmasters.

Here is the Cliff’s Notes version:

In 2003, Sarasota Realtor Marc Rasmussen secured a domain name, TheSarasotaMLS.com. Marc chose this domain name in part because of an article printed in the March 2002 issue of REALTOR Magazine by Michael Russer, aka “Mr. Internet”, that suggested a domain name such as [location]MLS.com was a sound idea.

Of note, Marc asked both the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and the Florida Association of Realtors (FAR) if it was OK to use this domain name. They both indicated they had no issue with it.

Over the years, Marc built his web site into a formidable marketing weapon and it became his primary source of business. Countless hours and dollars were poured into his site, and it ranked very well for many real estate search terms for the Sarasota area.

Fast forward five years to today.

The Sarasota Association of Realtors filed an ethics complaint against Marc apparently on behalf of the public good because they felt the domain name “TheSarasotaMLS.com” was misleading to the public. I guess they feel that the public is going to land on Marc’s web site and think that because of the domain name they are on the actual Sarasota MLS site. Personally, I give the general public a lot more credit than SAR appears to. I think anyone over the age of 10 and/or with an IQ above 40 or so will know precisely what kind of site they are on — Marc’s site is obviously a real estate agents site.

The results of Realtor ethics hearings are private. I think it’s pretty safe to assume though that the ethics hearing didn’t quite go the way the SAR hoped, as they continued to pursue Marc’s domain name by filing a complaint with ICANN (Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers) — a regulatory body charged with the responsibility to mediate and resolve domain disputes.

So a “jury of peers” (the Realtor ethics panel) finds no wrongdoing. The SAR continues their assault and sadly, in a split decision, the ICANN arbitrators ruled for the SAR, and ordered the domain name to be turned over to SAR.

As it stands now, Marc has filed a suit in Federal District Court in an attempt to save all that he has worked for over the years. It is thought that this action would place “on hold” the ICANN decision to transfer the domain over to the SAR, but alas, the SAR has redirected TheSarasotaMLS.com to their own association web site. (Isn’t that curious as the same public the SAR feels is so stupid is now being “mislead” again, this time by the SAR themselves!)

What should be done?

The Sarasota Association of Realtors is bent on destroying one of its own members

The answer is simple, and would take 5 minutes. All that needs to be done is have TheSarasotaMLS domain name properly redirected to Marc’s new domain — LuxurySarasotaRealEstate.com. This would allow Marc to keep the search results he has worked so hard for, AND make it so the “general public” would never see the domain name “TheSarasotaMLS.com”. That should (one would think) satisfy the SAR, as their concern for poor stupid John Q. Public would be satisfied. Little Johnny Public would never even see “TheSarasotaMLS” and could not be “mislead” into thinking he was on the MLS site itself.

But no, this isn’t good enough for the SAR. They want the domain name. Why? What good does it do them? All they are doing is destroying the work of their own, dues paying, association member. It makes no sense what-so-ever.

I can only think of two reasons the SAR would fight and fight over control of this domain name:

1) They want to hijack all the work Marc has poured into it for their own gain

2) They’re ignorant and they don’t understand how search engines work, and how a 301 redirect could solve this whole mess.

I’d like to give them the benefit of the doubt and say it’s reason #2. But given that they heard from an expert (Morgan Carey) at the ethics panel and still chose to go after the domain pretty much leaves us at reason number 1, doesn’t it?

If, as the SAR claims, they are only protecting the public and their members, then please explain why they’ve taken no steps to secure such “misleading” domain names like:

TheSarasotaMLS.net
TheSarasotaMLS.info
TheSarasotaMLS.org
The-Sarasota-MLS.com, .net, .info and .org

Or any of a host of other similar “misleading” names?

If the Sarasota Association of Realtors is so concerned about misleading domain names confusing the public, shouldn’t they fork over the $70 required to make sure no one grabs these names?

Huh. Sure seems like they have one and only one purpose in ripping off Marc Rasmussen and destroying his business…

DONATE to Marc’s legal fund here

Others opine:

  • Help Fight the Sarasota MLS Board
  • MLS Name Dispute Lands in Court
  • Sarasota MLS – is it a Genericized Trademark like Jello, Bandaid, SPAM, Tupperware, or Xerox?
  • SAR: The Real Cybersquat
  • Sarasota MLS – Luxury Sarasota Real Estate
  • Sarasota MLS Attacks Its Own Member
  • Sarasota REALTOR Files Federal Lawsuit To Keep MLS Domain Name
  • The SAR Pokie
  • The Sarasota MLS Bites One of the Hands That Feeds It
  • TheSarasotaMLS.com Is History
  • Sarasota MLS Board Dispute
  • SAR shuts down thesarasotamls dot com
  • Unite against the Sarasota MLS Board
  • Sarasota Association of REALTORS slaps one of its own
  • What does MLS mean?
  • Sarasota Association of REALTORS needs reputation management
  • A recap of the Sarasota Association of REALTORS action against Marc Rasmussen from a Trademark Attorney Blog
  • Sarasota MLS Attacks One of Their Paying Members
  • The future of the Multiple Listing Service ( MLS )
  • Real Estate is about service and sweat, not SEO
  • The Sarasota MLS
  • Sarasota Association of REALTORS attacks Marc the REALTOR
  • The Sarasota MLS invades Denver – aliens attack!
  • Sarasota Association of REALTORS – are they acting anti-competitive?
  • Free the MLS
  • Don’t cross the SAR
  • TheSarasotaMLS – a SAR members opinion
  • Marc the REALTOR vs Sarasota MLS
  • Sarasota Association of REALTORS vs REALTOR
  • Sarasota MLS begs for negative publicity
  • Ablazed by the Sarasota MLS – the fire continues
  • Sarasota Speaks
  • Board of REALTORS Gone Rabid, Sarasota MLS Board Out For Blood!!
  • Sarasota Association of Realtors are the Problem…. Be Part of the Solution
  • Fight the Power
  • theSarasotaMLS Link Party – The Marc Rasmussen Revolution and the Web 2.0 REALTOR Revolt
  • Sarasota  Association of REALTORS from NorthwestOfNormal
  • Sarasota Association of REALTORS – who does it really hurt?
  • NotTheSarasotaMLS.com
  • Sarasota Association of REALTORS actions are questioned
  • Pirates in Sarasota
  • Sarasota MLS Search
  • Sarasota Associations of Realtors (SAR) – Hijacking, Pillaging, and Hypocrisy Update
  • Do you have a post on this? Let me know and I’ll add it.


     

    Email This Post Email This Post Print This Post Print This Post

     

    Phoenix Homes Search

     



    Previous post: [ Phoenix Halloween Events ]
    Next post: [ And the Winners Are…. ]

     


    Thanks for reading! We value your thoughts and opinions, so please feel free to leave a comment. Please contact us if you have any questions or need help. You can also get automatic updates for this blog free via:
    pagely468x60_1

    { 5 trackbacks }

    Sarasota Association of REALTORS - They need my online reputation management help! :
    October 25, 2008 at 3:25 pm
    Sarasota Association of Realtors takes down its own member! « The Gulfshoreslife.com Team Service Providers
    October 26, 2008 at 6:40 am
    I Can Think of Only a Couple Reasons to Delete Comments | Real Central VA
    October 26, 2008 at 12:34 pm
    Sara Sota Needs Your Help | Denver SEO Guy Knox | Sarasota MLS
    October 26, 2008 at 9:51 pm
    Sarasota Association of Realtors: Where does one start? : NAR Wisdom
    October 27, 2008 at 5:36 pm

    { 43 comments… read them below or add one }

    1 Mike Price October 25, 2008 at 12:18 pm

    I REALLY wish I could say I was surprised by this. Sadly, I am not.

    Reply to this comment

    2 Carolyn Gjerde-Tu@Davis Real Estate October 25, 2008 at 1:19 pm

    Wow, the list keeps growing and growing. It is too bad that there are some agents (Brad in Reading) who don’t really understand what this issue is about.

    Reply to this comment

    3 Kevin Koitz October 25, 2008 at 2:06 pm

    @ Jay – Really well done…thanks. What a capricious, deceitful, “jealous”, dissolute group over there. What sent me beyond a boiling point was the “301″ing…Common!
    @ Hi Carolyn – we just need to continue to make “noise” – purposeful and well constructed “noise”.

    Reply to this comment

    4 knox October 25, 2008 at 2:10 pm

    Thanks for mentioning the fund!
    This is becoming the place to get the newly outraged voices listed.
    I admire your Ethics!

    Reply to this comment

    5 Jim Gatos October 25, 2008 at 2:12 pm

    Yup.. I agree.. and to think, you STILL have to pay these guys..

    I tell you, I think MLS and Realtor(R) should be government regulated…

    **Jim Gatos´s last blog post..Nice Street Views – Stanton St

    Reply to this comment

    6 Jay - The Phoenix Real Estate Guy October 25, 2008 at 2:16 pm

    “I admire your Ethics!” Well, at least someone does. ;)

    It saddens (and scares) me that SAR was able to hijack this domain, and in one swift swoop start sending all of Marc’s efforts spinning down the toilet.

    It’s a travesty.

    Reply to this comment

    7 Jaz October 25, 2008 at 2:29 pm

    Does SAR have the ethics to notify Marc of all the new leads they’re getting????

    OH YEAH – They’re Realtors that can take the business. Silly me. Ethics???

    Jaz

    **Jaz´s last blog post..Sarasota Association of Realtors = Pirates

    Reply to this comment

    8 Eric Blackwell October 25, 2008 at 2:39 pm

    Jay;

    Thanks for your support and leadership on this. What SAR did is a travesty. Also, thanks for collecting all of these links. I will be sending some links to y’all from EoS.

    Best to you.
    Eric

    **Eric Blackwell´s last blog post..Sarasota Association of REALTORS – They need my online reputation management help!

    Reply to this comment

    9 Charles Richey October 25, 2008 at 3:05 pm

    It is abuse of power. The site was 301′d to his new url, so their “issue” was a non-issue…but yet they went forward and hi-jacked his domain for the “good” of the members. If I was a member, I’d be nervous.

    **Charles Richey´s last blog post..Don’t cross the SAR

    Reply to this comment

    10 Hawaii real estate guy October 25, 2008 at 4:07 pm

    I had a similar thing happen to me. An agent from an outer island filed an ethics complaint against me for using “MLS” in one of my sites domain names. Luckily the Honolulu Board of Realtors Grievance Committee had enough sense to Dismiss it based on the following:

    Complaint did not rise to a possible violation of the Code, as the “MLS” is not trademarked by the National Association of Realtors (NAR) therefore cannot be banned from use by NAR. MLS has become a generic term for listings of available sales and rentals.

    This is just not right that Marc has to go through and everyone should do what ever they can to help him in this time of need. I am definitely making a donation of at least $100. Whether, it is a donation, posting about it on your blog with a link to his new site. They are definitely going after what he has worked hard to build and that is not right. What is wrong with people these days?

    I wish you the best Marc!

    Reply to this comment

    11 Matthew Rathbun October 25, 2008 at 5:34 pm

    Well, done; Sensei….

    **Matthew Rathbun´s last blog post..Twitter’ers: Friend or Foes?

    Reply to this comment

    12 vicki@davis real estate blog October 25, 2008 at 5:39 pm

    Jay:

    Great post that gives a clear, concise report on the situation. Also, you have provided the ultimate list of related blogs/articles.
    Well done.

    **vicki´s last blog post..Davis, a Bicycle Paradise

    Reply to this comment

    13 Monika October 25, 2008 at 5:42 pm

    I’ve been following this. I teach ethics and use this as one of the case studies for article 12. I hope Marc gets some satisfaction because once you read the whole story it sure puts a different spin on things.

    Reply to this comment

    14 Jay - The Phoenix Real Estate Guy October 25, 2008 at 5:44 pm

    @Eric – Cal did the work on the links, I just shamelessly copied them.

    @Charles – I’m not a member of the SAR, and it still makes me nervous. That any Association, whose main purpose it to help its members could make such an irrational ploy should be frightening to everyone. Your Association may be next…

    Reply to this comment

    15 Jim Duncan October 25, 2008 at 6:40 pm

    Jay –

    That an Association is actively working against one of its members is frightening and damaging to their and all Realtor Associations – for so many reasons.

    It’s more frustrating because there is likely only a small minority of Realtors who are both aware and somewhat knowledgeable about this issue.

    Reply to this comment

    16 Tina Fountain@Atlanta Real Estate October 25, 2008 at 6:52 pm

    Jay, thanks for spreading the word. It’s amazing that the SAR only had one outcome in mind – to take complete control of the name. No negotiating, no compromise, only give us the name!

    **Tina Fountain´s last blog post..Cobb County Luxury Homes

    Reply to this comment

    17 Gregory Bain October 25, 2008 at 7:09 pm

    Jay, the SAR is no different than any other AR out there. They are all money sucking as-beens who have found a way to make money off of hard working agents. They teach the classes “required” to get a license and hold the license. They set the dues to cover their salaries. They write rules and opinions that protect the Association and fleece the agent. They can’t sell real estate, so they control the way we sell it and pay them to do it. You will be able to re-write your story over and over again by just changing the initials and agents name. Domain names is a small part of their far reaching tenacles that destroy our practice of selling real estate. But, thanks for writing about it.

    Reply to this comment

    18 Daniel Bates October 26, 2008 at 4:25 am

    This is the same NAR that says you can claim to be an “E-Pro” if you can sit relatively still in a class for a few hours, pay them money, and answer your email. Pretty steep credentials….but the “ethics badge” we all wear (symbolically…unless you made one yourself and then you’re a dork) as Realtors has only involves two of those steps, so that should tell you something right there.

    Reply to this comment

    19 Matt@Fountain Hills Real Estate October 26, 2008 at 12:21 pm

    @Daniel Bates… dude, I almost spit my ice tea out while LMAO. I got my e-Pro designation when it first came out, and you know what, you will not find it on my sites, my letterhead, my cards, etc. because it doesn’t even deserve to be mentioned. I felt ‘duped’ 20 minutes into the online class I took.

    As for Marc, NAR needs to step in and reverse this soon, IMO. I just came across TheCityNameMLS.com (real city name w/held so as not to start another association war) on REW in a recent thread today. So, unless NAR makes this a rule across the country, I don’t see how they can just stand by while an association that they (NAR) govern picks on one individual.

    Matt Pellerin – Realtor Real Estate Agent

    **Matt´s last blog post..Scottsdale Quarter to be more like a Mac than PC

    Reply to this comment

    20 John @ Maryland Real Estate October 27, 2008 at 11:32 am

    It is absolutely criminal that they did this!!!

    **John´s last blog post..Hanover Real Estate

    Reply to this comment

    21 Sara Sota October 27, 2008 at 1:50 pm

    I’m donating all my ad revenue to this cause. EVERYONE should dedicate one domain to this. it ads up.
    http://www.NotTheSarasotaMLS.com/

    Reply to this comment

    22 Morgan Carey October 27, 2008 at 4:11 pm

    Jay thanks for the support – I asked Marc if he would put together a post with a time line in it (I had suggested it to a few people as a potential topic, but then I realized on Marc had the straight goods) and he has been kind enough to do so. You can read Marc’s timeline on this own blog here: http://www.luxurysarasotarealestate.com/blog/sarasota/marc-rasmussen-vs-sarasota-association-of-realtors-over-thesarasotamlscom/show/

    For those writing about this, please include that blog post in your list of assets as it has more reliable information pertaining to that actual sequence of events etc –

    Once again, thanks to Jay (And everyone) for being so awesome in supporting my good friend in this time of extreme stress. We speak several times a day via messenger, and he can’t say enough about how amazing you folks truly are.

    **Morgan Carey´s last blog post..Recent Vero Beach Real Estate Sales (October 21 – October 27, 2008)

    Reply to this comment

    23 James Boyer@Chatham NJ Real Estate October 27, 2008 at 4:40 pm

    Thanks for posting about this crime. The Sarasota Association of REALTORS leadership board seems to have only one purpous in mind in taking Marc’s domain, getting the 10’s of thousands of links Marc has built to the domain. I am guessing the there are going to be a few SAR board members with damaged online reputations.

    Reply to this comment

    24 Stephen Douglas October 28, 2008 at 2:16 am

    What’s sad about this is that Marc had the right idea from the start, but depended on a “higher level authority” regarding the rights to the domain name. One of the longest running jokes within the domain industry (aftermarket/development companies and investors) was that the real estate industry, selling property in the real world, couldn’t get it in their heads that the virtual world property was cheaper, and appreciated in value much faster. However, that’s changing now.

    If Marc had just purchased a domain name with his geo-specific location and his generic services (without infringing, even with permission, on the TM holder’s license), he wouldn’t be in this situation right now. He’d be doing well, based on the thousands of hours of work on his website over the years, and his domain name/s (good to buy a few similar domains to point to the site) would be all his.

    It is stories like you publish here that are really warning agents and brokers nationwide to the fact that their own efforts to promote their individual work can be quickly robbed from them by the company they work for, or even the listing services, realtor services, etc.

    As a domain consultant for five years, in just the last two years, over half of my clients have been real estate attorneys and brokers who are buying up domain names and promoting their services SEPARATELY from the “freebie site” or other “gimmees” offered by their brokerages. I advise all my real estate business clients to OWN their own domains and create their own websites. A productive blogsite, which can bring you in tons of new customers, can cost as little as $300 – $500. A killer domain name, which secures your local area and defines your services, (most of these domains are already owned by domain speculators) will cost you from $250 – $50,000, depending on how serious you want to get.

    For example, I own PalmSpringsHome.org and DramaticHomes.com. The first domain describes a “geo-specific” product (a home in Palm Springs) which can be set up as a blog describing the Palm Springs area, including recreation, hot restaurants, services, shopping locations, etc. Included in this blog will be YOU talking about how great the area is, and promoting your links and contact info to your users.

    A blog is very important to a “customer based service” like the real estate industry, because for a half hour every day, you can write 300 words on your blog giving little bits of relevant info to whoever visits your blog. You can give this blogsite address out on your biz cards, invite your customers to login and sign up to receive notices, and you also excite the major search engines with relevant content they love to “crawl” and add to their customers’ relevant search queries. Soon, you’ll find hundreds of potential clients coming to your blog to find out what great tips you’re going to offer.

    It’s no secret anymore that a generic descriptive domain name is very valuable. You might spend $5,000 to get a very clear and descriptive domain this year, but next year, it only costs $10 to renew, and you get all the same or better leads and exposure. Additionally, the money you invest in an “aftermarket domain” never goes away, especially when you work on it and create new links and content. The search engines catalog all of your work, and it makes the value of your domain name appreciate.

    I advise any SERIOUS real estate business person to look into purchasing domain names that define their experience, focus, location/service, or even their full name.

    I’d be glad to answer questions at no cost for your readers at:
    http://www.successclick.com

    cheers,

    Stephen Douglas
    Successful Domain Management™
    Blog: Successclick.com
    DomainRelevance.com
    “Own Your Competition™”

    **Stephen Douglas´s last blog post..SHOULD WE SELL OR KEEP OUR DOMAINS?

    Reply to this comment

    25 D. Patrick Lewis October 28, 2008 at 7:56 am

    Great post Jay, the whole situation disturbing, especially the ICANN decision. I wish Marc all the best in fighting this.

    Reply to this comment

    26 Matt@Fountain Hills Real Estate October 28, 2008 at 11:31 am

    Jay that is one heck of a comment you’ve got there from Stephen! What a huge pat on the back for me. ;-)

    I learned early, real early – and the hard way, that I needed a generic prod/serve domain after NAR took away my rights to use PhoenixRealtor.com. I had bought PhoenixRealtor.com for $1000 many years back and was less than a year into building and promoting it when NAR wrote to me. And to tell the truth, I couldn’t be happier that they did stop me (especially so early on), because it prompted me to search out a domain I liked and buy it. Enter PhoenixHomes.com…

    Yet here I sit today with about 30 domains I consider valuable, 2 of which I consider “whales”: PhoenixHomes.com and ScottsdaleHomes.com. Both were well worth the cash investment I had to cough up IMO. And, I am not done… I am in the middle of a 2 week long domain purchase right now. :-) Though, I would sell some of the domains I currently have (inquire within and let me know your niche if interested, I have local domains only).

    Sure, I would’ve built the same sites, with the same content and designs that I have today using different domains, but I am so glad NAR stepped in when they did! Because I feel I got a good deal on my “whale domains” based on when I bought them. And, I feel that the ease of remembering the domain (once I do get someone to the site) is priceless.

    Marc will come out a better, stronger man from all of this. I have no doubt. But those mere words do not take the sting out of what SAR has done.

    Matt Pellerin – Realtor Real Estate Agent

    **Matt´s last blog post..Scottsdale Quarter to be more like a Mac than PC

    Reply to this comment

    27 Linda Craft October 28, 2008 at 5:04 pm

    As a long time Real Estate Agent in Raleigh, NC, I know just how frustrating it must be for Marc to (maybe) be losing all the hard work he has done in increasing his site traffic. I hope everything turns out OK for him, but I am sure either way the court decides, he can get all his traffic to go with him to his new site and perhaps surpass where he is now.

    Reply to this comment

    28 Northwest Living October 28, 2008 at 6:09 pm

    Jay – thanks for using the strength of your site to support an important topic like this. My belief is this is only the beginning of the story. The NAR, local MLS’s, and tons of real estate agents across the country look at all the successful agents sites with such envy…it’s inevitable that we will be tested more and more in the future. If they can’t beat us, they will just pass more laws in the future…just to level the playing field. Just my two cents…you can all guess at what I’m thinking with all this.

    Now… what bothers most of us Internet savvy real estate agents is the theft of Marc’s hard earned work on his Internet links for his site theSarasotamls.com. It’s one thing to have your head in the sand and fight Marc out of jealousy over his success on Internet rankings, but entirely another when SAR steals his property and redirects his hard work on linking towards their own site. This is an absolute outrage that they were awarded even one link for doing absolutely nothing to earn it. That’s bull….

    **Northwest Living´s last blog post..September Existing Home Sales up 5.5%

    Reply to this comment

    29 kermit@minneapolis real estate October 29, 2008 at 3:23 pm

    Don’t you just love it when the MLS board goes after its members under the guise of “protecting the public?”

    I had an old page on my site that had a title tag in it that said something like “Minnesota MLS listings” which is really not misleading because you can fill out a form on the site so I can send you all of the actual MLS listing datasheets that you want. The board said I was “implying that the visitor could search the entire Minnesota MLS” directly from the site. I had totally forgotten about the page until the board sent me an email threatening to cut me off if I did not remove the offending term within five days.

    I am thankful that the board did not have issue with my entire site or domain name.

    Interestingly, all of our big nationwide competitors use the term “Search the MLS” with impunity, giving a disadvantage to the local mls board members. Maybe I don’t understand how the system works or legalities involved, but I am wondering why they can’t just cut the feed to these big out-of-state-entities.

    **kermit´s last blog post..Hutchinson MN Real Estate for Sale. Only $89,900!

    Reply to this comment

    30 James@Housing Market October 30, 2008 at 12:48 pm

    This is just another example of the anti-competitive nature of NAR and local boards of REALTORS. Lets be very honest on this subject there are a number of different domains that are using the MLS in them in the Sarasota market. And the only one that the Sarasota MLS has gone after is Marc’s what that tells me is that they only came after him because he was out ranking them. I now hope that the DOJ comes down on the boards like never before. It is not consumers that need protection from horrible agents that miss use a generic term like MLS, it is agents as well as consumers that need protection against the Oligopoly known as the association of REALTORS.

    I believe that as agents we should have the choice of whether or not we want to be part of the association of REALTORS as I have come to the point where I no longer have any desire to be a member.

    **James´s last blog post..The housing market in Houston is seeing an interesting trend in leasing.

    Reply to this comment

    31 Gregory Bain October 30, 2008 at 1:56 pm

    James, I feel the same way. But, that’s like being over 50 and not being a member of AARP. Where will all the Lobbyists go?

    Maybe, they will all become carpetbaggers like Stephen Douglas. Telling us how stupid we are and for a fee they will help us in the complicated world of seo, blogging, and domain names in that internet thingamajig.

    the deep deep pockets of real estate agents every where

    Reply to this comment

    32 James@Housing Market in Houston October 30, 2008 at 3:05 pm

    @Gregory – I like your sarcastic wit! I wonder home much it will cost me to get help with that SOE, I think you said logging, and the whatamakalit. You know the thing that I use on my computer. Oh by the way I know how to turn mine on now, all by my lonesome. Pretty cool, huh.

    **James´s last blog post..The housing market in Houston is seeing an interesting trend in leasing.

    Reply to this comment

    33 Stephen Douglas November 1, 2008 at 6:34 am

    Gregory Bain states that I am a “carpetbagger” because I understand the domain industry and have invested smartly in securing online “land”. The definition of a carpetbagger, according to Webster is “a person perceived as an unscrupulous opportunist”. Unscrupulous?

    What Gregory doesn’t tell you is that he makes domain investments similar to how I advise businesses. He bought a geo-specific domain name for his freebie site “littleeggharborhomes.com” and “ask4greg.com”. But notice I said “freebie site”. He points his decent domain investments to a “freebie” hosting source, “realestate.com”, thereby enhancing realestate.com’s SE positioning and not owning his content, seniority, comments, photos, and anything else he wishes to add to sell his services “Whether you are buying or selling a home, hire someone like me, who wants to earn your business.” Seems hypocritical that Gregory would call me an unscrupulous salesman for offering my “virtual real estate” advice, while he asks for the same for his brick and mortar business.

    Bain seems to be smart in some areas, but not in the area of libel. He should fear my attorney contacting him for making libelous remarks about me in a public forum. I’ll think about that for the rest of the year, and make a decision in 2009 on whether to file. Lucky for me, I have several attorneys who practice in the NJ area..

    The domain industry is a legitimate “virtual real estate” industry. Gregory Bain bought domains names to PROVE my comments. He just wasn’t smart enough to host his sites separately from another company who gains from his efforts, and can shut him out when they want.

    For those of you who want to buy a domain for a few thousand dollars and see it appreciate in value in a year or less to 10 times that amount, then LEARN THE DOMAIN BUSINESS.

    Time to get real and understand what stands before you. If you think paying money for college tuition to learn how to expand your knowledge in the domain or real estate business makes your professor a “carpetbagger”, then drop out, stay ignorant, vote McCailin, and most definitely suffer because of eight years of GW Bush manipulation.

    I posted here to offer sincere help to real estate brokers. Obviously, I touched a nerve with some people who feel they won’t be able to “catch up”. Heaven forbid I should get paid for my expertise!

    Good luck to all.

    Stephen Douglas
    http://www.successclick.com

    **Stephen Douglas´s last blog post..GODADDY TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT WATCH

    Reply to this comment

    34 Daniel Bates November 1, 2008 at 8:56 am

    Well this is all starting to sound like the political attack ads we’re all too familiar with, which thankfully will soon end and we can all return to our precious Geico Gecko and Big Mac ads, YAY!

    @Stephen – I think the “unscrupulous” aspect of the comment (although he didn’t use the word) may have come from your two page self promoting comment. You obviously made the comment in an effort to advertise your business on this popular site, but in the process insulted most of the readers here (probably unknowingly) by implying that none of us were smart enough to purchase high quality domain names and setup a site of our own. We’re all in the same boat here buddy, just real estate agents trying to make a living. Some know more about the web, some know less (most of Jay’s reader’s know more!). Maybe unscrupulous is a poor choice of word, but I think that many might agree that your initial sales pitch and the equally-lengthy lawyer threat that pursued have not been the best advertisement for the services that you (and hundreds of thousands of other companies) offer. Best of Luck

    **Daniel Bates´s last blog post..McClellanville Creek Cleanup and Fishing Tournament

    Reply to this comment

    35 Jay - The Phoenix Real Estate Guy November 1, 2008 at 8:18 pm

    I really don’t want to delete any comments and I certainly don’t want to close this post to comments.

    @Stephen – your comment was VERY close to violating my comment policy due to advertising. I let it stand as written because it did provide some valuable insight.

    @Gregory – that same comment policy includes no personal attacks.

    This particular topic is a very emotional one, and it’s easy to let tempers and feelings get out of hand.

    I respectfully request that the two involved parties let it go or take it somewhere else.

    Thanks!

    Reply to this comment

    36 James@Houston Realtors November 2, 2008 at 2:24 am

    @Daniel Bates – Well said!

    Reply to this comment

    37 Stephen Douglas November 2, 2008 at 3:11 am

    I appreciate your comments, Jay and Daniel. It’s true that when I take the time to write an informative article for an hour as a contribution to somebody’s blog, reviewing it multiple times so it’s not full of spelling and grammatical mistakes, that I’d like to think I’ll get some customers from my time. This is true of all of us, and denying it is somewhat silly.

    I’m not filing any lawsuits for libel. Greg can rest easy (not that he was worried). However, I stated that to make a point: Just because I’m here making a statement that is TRUE regarding the real estate industry’s slow take on the domain industry doesn’t mean I’m a “carpetbagger” or “unscrupulous” as Gregory insinuated. I provided what I believed to be informative and helpful information on this well-run blog. I’ve seen hundreds of similar blogs that don’t come close to the conversation here, and I don’t waste my time posting on them. However, this blog’s professionalism lured me into taking my valuable time to post. It’s not unreasonable or unusual that the blog owner rewards informative posts with allowing some sort of mini-promotion of the poster. I do it all the time on my domain blog, within reason.

    I appreciate reading all your comments here. I’m pretty impressed with this blog and the owner of the blog, and the contributors. Also, I produced a live modeling event in Scottsdale about 20 years ago, and one of the photos is on my facebook pages. I liked Phoenix/Scottsdale and the people who lived there. It’s a great place and growing exponentially.

    My final point for Jay’s readers: Go ahead and rent out spots on big real estate websites for your basic info pages, but to be a real businessman, buy domains that define your areas and your expertise (like Greg Bain did) , but build a blog or a website SEPARATELY from the “directories” and put all your content on your own hosted site. It costs about $10 a month for your own hosted site.

    I make good money advising real estate business people (as just one business sector) on how to do this, and nobody has ever called me unscrupulous. My Linkedin profile is on my blog where you can see my accomplishments and recommendations from people I’ve worked for and with. I’ve sold over $25 million in domain names, and made several million in consulting in this area. The things you see and take for granted are tied into the business and associates I work with. (iReport.com, a domain owned by CNN, was sold by a domain expert named Rick Schwartz for $750,000 this year. When you see “i Report” on CNN, think about this. Rick may have bought that domain for less than $100. Nice return on that investment. More info:
    http://www.ricksblog.com/my_weblog/2008/01/ireportcom-and.html)

    Thanks Jay, for the opportunity to speak.

    Wishing everyone great success,

    Stephen Douglas
    http://www.successclick.com

    **Stephen Douglas´s last blog post..GODADDY TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT WATCH

    Reply to this comment

    38 Stephen Douglas November 2, 2008 at 3:26 am

    Dang, one more thing I forgot to add:

    Daniel, you said: “Maybe unscrupulous is a poor choice of word, but I think that many might agree that your initial sales pitch and the equally-lengthy lawyer threat that pursued have not been the best advertisement for the services that you (and hundreds of thousands of other companies) offer.

    Your last sentence about “hundreds of thousands” of companies that offer my similar services is very wrong. There are only about 15 legitimate domain name professional consultants that are recognized in our industry. From what I’m told, I could be one of them. I’m not counting the “auto-appraisal” websites that appraise your domains, but even those services are limited to less than 50, as far as I know.

    Okay, just had to clear that up. I promise I won’t intrude on your space again unless invited.

    Success to all!

    **Stephen Douglas´s last blog post..GODADDY TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT WATCH

    Reply to this comment

    39 Jay - The Phoenix Real Estate Guy November 2, 2008 at 7:11 am

    Stephen –

    First, thanks for all the kind words about the blog, it’s very appreciated. There are some great readers and commenters (and guest authors) here.

    The self-promotion and “advertising” is always tricky for me. I’ve had people come here and do ridiculous things — such as a real estate agent, IN PHOENIX, promoting a listing or their area of expertise. Sorry, but if you want to do that, do it on your own blog.

    Usually it’s much more fuzzy, and if the comment contributes good info, I’ll let it stand. I just don’t want the comments to turn into an advertising section. I moderate with a very light touch. I also have *all* comment URL’s set to “dofollow”, including the “Comment Luv” that adds the commenters last blog post. (embedded URLs tend to get flagged and go into moderation — that’s why some of your comment didn’t appear immediately and others did). I think the dofollow is a pretty decent reward.

    I also have paying advertisers, so I have to be careful and respect their positions.

    was sold by a domain expert named Rick Schwartz for $750,000 this year

    I bet whoever sold it to him for $100 is slamming their head against a wall right now.

    I promise I won’t intrude on your space again unless invited.

    You’re welcome any time.

    Reply to this comment

    40 Hector Lesende November 7, 2008 at 3:27 pm

    Excellent post Jay, after the SARjacking the SAR’s site is ranking very high for most Sarasota real estate keywords. I wonder what the SAR will do with all the leads generated by Marc’s hard work.

    Hector Lesende
    Miami Real Estate

    Reply to this comment

    41 Cal@Gulf Shores Real Estate Blog November 19, 2008 at 6:02 pm
    42 chris July 9, 2009 at 2:54 pm

    I keep some geo type real estate domain names as an investment. I would not pay $10 for “TheSarasotaMLS.com”. As and investment grade domain name is is not very good. Clearly the real value in this domain name was the work the owner had put into it over the years.

    SarasotaMLS.org which is a better name is available for reg fee right now.

    Reply to this comment

    43 Rowell Auctions February 24, 2010 at 10:23 am

    This should certainly be a wake up. Make sure your website is renewed and possibly by the .info .org of your site to be sure.
    Rowell Auctions´s last blog ..100192 – 699 Reynolds Street Augusta GA 30901 – February 16th thru March 2nd My ComLuv Profile

    Reply to this comment

    Leave a Comment

    Read this blog's Comment Policy

    CommentLuv Enabled

    Previous post: Half of Arizona Homeowners are Underwater. 23% Nationwide…

    Next post: Happy Thanksgiving from Phoenix Real Estate Guy!